Home > Newsletters

The Yale Initiative for the Interdisciplinary Study of Antisemitism
Newsletter
Volume 3 No. 3

26 September 2008

SAVE THE DATE

 

YIISA Director, Dr. Charles Small, will engage in a conversation with Wall Street Journal writer and editor, Bret Stephens.

Monday, December 1st @ 8:15pm

Buttenwieser Hall, Lexington Avenue and 92nd Street, New York City

“Radical Islam and the Nuclear Bomb:  Understanding Contemporary Genocidal Anti-Semitism”

Sponsor:         92Y  --  Please click here for more information.

 

LECTURES OF INTEREST

 

Friday, September 26th  – Saturday, September 27th

Luce Hall Auditorium, 34 Hillhouse Avenue

“Reconfiguring a Region: Opportunities & Challenges in the Middle East”

Keynote Address: Robert Malley, International Crisis Group

Also featuring:     Featuring 25 leading scholars, diplomats, and policy analysts.

Sponsor:               Council on Middle East Studies

Contact:                cmes@yale.edu -- Please click here for a full program.

Thursday, October 2nd @ 8:00pm

Davenport College, 248 York Street

Performance by Mamak Khadem, one of Iran’s leading female singers

Sponsor:         Yale Persian Society and Davenport College

Contact:          ypsofficers@gmail.com -- Tickets $25, $15 for college students

 

 

SPECIAL ARTICLES OF INTEREST

 

Charge Ahmadinejad with incitement to genocide, say former U.S., Israeli envoys to UN

(Haartez) Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad's statements professing a desire to "wipe Israel off the map" are sufficient to serve as the basis for charges of incitement to genocide, two prominent former diplomats from the United States and Israel. Dore Gold, Jerusalem's former envoy to the United Nations, and former U.S. ambassador Richard Holbrooke are among a group of scholars, lawmakers, and survivors of genocide from Rwanda and Sudan who gathered in Washington on Tuesday for a conference examining the plausibility of being the Iranian president before an international tribunal.

Click here to read

 

Summary of Ambassador Richard Holbrooke's Speech at the "State-Sanctioned Incitement to Genocide: What Can Be Done?" Conference Co-sponsored by YIISA 

(Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs) "My theme is that words matter," asserted Ambassador Holbrooke in his address to the conference.  Ambassador Holbrooke recounted how in 1933, his grandfather in Hamburg decided to leave Germany after reading Mein Kampf. Ambassador Holbrooke lauded the work of Ambassador Dore Gold and his colleagues who "have done a brilliant job of bringing the issue of Ahmadinejad’s incitement to world attention."  But, Holbrooke cautioned that "people haven't focused energy on the core reason that Iran is uniquely dangerous--because of specific threats Iran has issued to another country based on ethnicity."

Click here to read and watch video

 

ARTICLES OF INTEREST

 

IRAN

 Contact man's murder delays Syria nuclear probe: IAEA

(Agence France-Presse

The UN atomic watchdog's probe into alleged illicit nuclear work in Syria has been delayed because the agency's contact man in Syria was murdered, IAEA chief Mohamed ElBaradei revealed Thursday.  "The reason that Syria has been late in providing additional information (is) that our interlocutor has been assassinated in Syria," ElBaradei told a closed-door session of the International Atomic Energy Agency's 35-member board. A recording of his remarks was obtained by AFP.

Click here to read

 

Everyone Needs to Worry About Iran
(Wall Street Journal) An opinion piece by Richard Holbrooke, R. James Woolsey, Dennis B. Ross and Mark D. Wallace – “We may have different political allegiances and worldviews, yet we share a common concern -- Iran's drive to be a nuclear state. We believe that Iran's desire for nuclear weapons is one of the most urgent issues facing America today, because even the most conservative estimates tell us that they could have nuclear weapons soon.”

Click here to read

Wiesel urges U.N. to indict Iranian president

(International Herald Tribune) Nobel laureate and Holocaust survivor Elie Wiesel urged the United Nations on Monday to indict Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad for inciting genocide rather than allow him to speak at the U.N. General Assembly. Wiesel spoke to thousands of people at a rally to urge world leaders to stop Iran from obtaining nuclear weapons -- something Tehran denies it is trying to do, but which Western powers suspect is the true aim of its nuclear program.

Click here to read

 Where’s the Outrage, Turtle Bay?

(National Review) Iranian extremist Mahmoud Ahmadinejad has wangled invitations from various patrons of New York polite society this week, seeking “dialogue” and discussion, during the opening of the United Nations General Assembly. He is, after all, president of Iran. But we should harbor no illusions about what the man is up to. Ahmadinejad has revealed his agenda. He is not just against Israel. He is against the Jewish community in its entirety.

Click here to read

A reply to Ahmadinejad

(Haaretz) Israel is justifiably concerned about the naivete with which Ahmadinejad was received by the American media, as well as the world's growing tendency to view him as a legitimate leader and cease efforts to stop the Iranian nuclear program. The calls by the Iranian president to destroy Israel deserve the strongest condemnation, and we must continue the diplomatic struggle against them. But Israel must not be boxed into the corner where Ahmadinejad wants it and join an exchange of threats and counterthreats, which would only intensify the anxiety in Israel and possibly lead to a confrontation.

Click here to read

Again: Antisemitism, welcomed and cheered

(National Review) Anne Bayefsky writes, “The United Nations has become the largest global purveyor of antisemitism in the world today.  In the full knowledge that the president of Iran denies the Holocaust and advocates the destruction of the U.N. member state of Israel, the U.N. invited him to mount the dais and gave him a megaphone.”

Click here to read

Making a joke of the UN

(National Post) Israeli Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni -- who could soon be that country's prime minister -- says it would be "absurd" to elect Iran to a seat on the United Nation's Security Council, and she's right. But absurd is the UN's stock in trade. This is the world organization, remember, that ignores epic human rights abuses in places such as Darfur and Cuba, even as it passes endless resolutions slamming Israel. Ideas that are obviously ridiculous often strike the UN's collective brain trust as perfectly sensible.

Click here to read

Nuclear Agency Says Iran Has Improved Enrichment

(NY Times) Iran has substantially improved the efficiency of its centrifuges that produce enriched uranium, the International Atomic Energy Agency said Monday, indicating that the nation has overcome some of the technical challenges that had plagued its enrichment program.

Click here to read

Iran hasn't answered questions on nuclear program, arms control chief says

(LA Times) The world's top arms control authority harshly criticized Iran on Monday, saying it had failed to clear up questions about its nuclear past, while the Islamic Republic accused the agency of becoming a tool for Western pressure. Mohamed ElBaradei, secretary-general of the International Atomic Energy Agency, told his board of directors at an annual meeting here that his inspectors failed to get Iranians to clear up questions related to documents allegedly showing that Iran engaged in a series of experiments and studies consistent with the operation of a clandestine nuclear weapons program.

Click here to read

EU: Iran closer to nuke arms capacity

(USA Today) Iran is nearing the ability to arm a nuclear warhead even if it insists its atomic activities are peaceful, the European Union warned Wednesday. In comments prepared for delivery to the International Atomic Energy Agency's 35 board members, the EU also asserted that Iran appeared to have had a past nuclear arms program despite its denials.

Click here to read

Russia Won’t Meet With U.S. on Iranian Nuclear Program

(NY Times) Russia said on Tuesday that it would not participate in a meeting with the United States this week to discuss Iran’s nuclear program, the most significant indication yet of how Russia’s war with Georgia has spoiled relations regarding other security issues.

Click here to read

Mystery surrounds hijacked Iranian ship

(Long War Journal) A tense standoff is underway in northeastern Somalia between pirates, Somali authorities, and Iran over a suspicious merchant vessel and its mysterious cargo. Hijacked late last month in the Gulf of Aden, the MV Iran Deyanat remains moored offshore in Somali waters and inaccessible for inspection. Its declared cargo consists of minerals and industrial products, however, Somali and regional officials directly involved in the negotiations over the ship and who spoke to The Long War Journal are convinced that it was heading to Eritrea to deliver small arms and chemical weapons to Somalia's Islamist insurgents.

Click here to read

EUROPE       

 Anti-Jew, Muslim attitudes rise in Europe: survey

(Washington Post) Anti-Muslim and anti-Jewish feelings are rising in several major European countries, according to a worldwide survey released on Wednesday. The Washington-based Pew Research Center's global attitude survey found 46 percent of Spanish, 36 percent of Poles and 34 percent of Russians view Jews unfavorably, while the same was true for 25 percent of Germans, and 20 percent of French.

Click here to read

New Report Finds Violent Hate Crime on the Rise

(Human Rights First) Incidents of violent hate crime targeting a number of minority groups are increasing or occurring at historically high levels in many of the Organization of Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) member-states, as governments fail to combat such crimes, a new report finds.

Click here to read

 Paris: Attack on teens was anti-Semitic

(Jewish Telegraphic Agency) Three Jewish teens in Paris were attacked recently because of their faith, a French Jewish leader reiterated. A Jewish suspect charged with participating in the group assault of the kipot-wearing teens on Sept. 6 "intervened at a later time," said Richard Prasquier, the president of the French Jewish umbrella organization CRIF in an interview with the daily Le Figaro published Saturday.

Click here to read

 Sarkozy slams anti-Semitism

(Jewish Telegraphic Agency) French President Nicolas Sarkozy condemned anti-Semitism and all forms of racism as he accepted an award for statesmanship. "When a Jew is insulted in France, when a Jew is ill treated because he is a Jew, it affects Jews throughout the world," Sarkozy said Tuesday in New York upon receiving the World Statesman Award from the Appeal of Conscience Foundation. "Anti-Semitism is a stain" that must be eradicated.

Click here to read

Holocaust scholars urge al-Bashir prosecution

(Washington Post) Holocaust scholars appealed Monday to the International Criminal Court prosecutor to pursue his indictment of Sudan's president on charges of genocide in Darfur. The 130 scholars signed a letter to chief prosecutor Luis Moreno-Ocampo urging him to resist pressure to drop the case against Omar al-Bashir. They warned against putting politics ahead of justice, and said al-Bashir's prosecution would "deter future atrocities."

Click here to read

NORTH AMERICA

US textbooks misrepresent Jews, Israel

(The Jerusalem Post)  American elementary and high school textbooks contain many "gross misrepresentations" of Judaism, Christianity and Israel, according to a book-length study released this week by the San Francisco-based Institute for Jewish and Community Research.  "It is shocking to discover that history and geography textbooks widely used in America's elementary and secondary classrooms contain some of the very same inaccuracies about Christianity, Judaism and the Middle East as those [used] in Iran," the IJCR said in a summary of the findings of the five-year study.

Click here to read

 Prof sees mixed picture on hatred, Shoa denial

(New Jersey Jewish News)  Deborah Lipstadt describes herself as basically an optimistic person. That might account for her saying that in some ways there is less anti-Semitism than in the past.  “Universities that once had quotas now have Jewish presidents, law firms that once would not hire Jews now have Torah study sessions at lunch, people who would not socialize with Jews now have grandchildren who are marrying Jews (I am not sure if that is a better or a worse),” the Emory University professor wrote in an e-mail.

Click here to read

 The Dangerous Brew

(New York Sun)  As an organization committed first to combat anti-Semitism but also to work against all forms of prejudice, the Anti-Defamation League often talks against a "hierarchy of hate," a competition for victimhood among minorities. Our philosophy is that the emphasis should fall on the commonalities of those who are targeted for hate as the best way to form strong coalitions.Every once in a while an event takes place, however, that jars us out of that kind of approach. The speech by President Ahmadinejad of Iran before the United Nations General Assembly on September 23 is one such event.

Click here to read

Exploring anti-Semitism is Freud's work

(Daily Pennsylvanian) Penn and the Psychoanalytic Center of Philadelphia co-sponsored the program "Anti-Semitism in the Freud Case Histories" last night at Steinhardt Hall. The program, part of the Freud, Franklin and Beyond series of lectures on psychology, culture and society, was co-sponsored in conjunction with Hillel and the Jewish Studies Program.

Click here to read

Building bridges to fight anti-Semitism in Quebec

(Globe and Mail) The mayor of a quiet resort town north of Montreal says a spate of seemingly anti-Semitic acts against visibly Jewish residents is nothing more than the rogue behaviour of a few teenagers. But the recent incidents in Ste-Agathe-des-Monts, a popular weekend and summer destination for members of Montreal's Hasidic Jewish community, has roused calls for diversity training for youths and more cultural events bridging the two cultures.

Click here to read

WEEKLY QUOTES

Source - Canadian Institute for Jewish Research

"The dignity, integrity and rights of the European and American people are being played with by a small but deceitful number of people called Zionists. Although they are miniscule minority, they have been dominating an important portion of the financial and monetary centers as well as the political decision-making centers of some European countries and the U.S. in a deceitful, complex and furtive manner. It is deeply disastrous to witness that some presidential or premiere nominees in some big countries have to visit these people, take part in their gatherings, swear their allegiance and commitment to their interests in order to attain financial or media support...

This means that the great people of America and various nations of Europe need to obey the demands and wishes of a small number of acquisitive and invasive people. These nations are spending their dignity and resources on the crimes and occupations and the threats of the Zionist network against [their] will...

Today, the Zionist regime is on a definite slope to collapse, and there is no way for it to get out of the cesspool created by itself and its supporters…

In Palestine, 60 years of carnage and invasion is still ongoing at the hands of some criminal and occupying Zionists. They have forged a regime through collecting people from various parts of the world and bringing them to other people's land by displacing, detaining and killing the true owners of that land... The Security Council cannot do anything and sometimes, under pressure from few bullying powers, even paves the way for supporting these Zionist murderers...”

-- ­Excerpts from Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad’s hate-filled speech at the United Nations General Assembly. A round of applause followed these passages. Ambassadors of Israel and the United States were not present for the address. (EyeontheUN.org, Sept. 24)

 “Yesterday, on this very stage, the Iranian leader renewed the darkest anti-Semitic libel­the protocols of the elders of Zion. An attempt to bring to life one of the ugliest plots of history.  Their despicable denial of the Holocaust is a mockery of indisputable evidence, a cynical offense to survivors of the horror. Contradictory to the resolutions adopted by this assembly. … Iranian support for Hizbullah divided Lebanon. Its support for Hamas split the Palestinians and postpones the establishment of the Palestinian State. … Tehran combines long-range missiles and short-range minds. It is pregnant with tragedies. The General Assembly and the Security Council bear responsibility to prevent agonies before they take place.  Israel has shown that democracies can defend themselves. We do not intend to change. Terrorism did not solve a single problem. It never has, and never will. … If small groups of violent killers are allowed to threaten innocent masses, the world will be without order or security. A hopeless battleground. The free world must unite to combat it.” ­Israel’s President Shimon Peres, slamming Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad’s speech at the United Nations, and calling Ahmadinejad’s appearance before the  General Assembly a disgrace. (Ynet News, Sept. 24)

 "When he talks about the decay of Israel, he has in mind the collapse of the Soviet Union, i.e. he just describes historical process, people say. But [proclaiming that Israel must be wiped [off] the face of the world] suggests we're not talking about political theory. If the West will fail to respond to Iran's incitement to genocide, Iran will feel it can act. Deterring Iran now is vital, not only for the security of Israel, but of all of us.”­ Ambassador Dore Gold, Jerusalem's former envoy to the United Nations, arguing that Mahmoud Ahmadinejad’s statements violate the 1948 UN convention on the prevention and punishment of the crimes of genocide. “Divestment can only have a limited success,” Gold added. “It's very much worth doing, but unless you put Iranians in a position that the South African government was in in the eighties, it won't work. His talk amounts to a violation of the genocide convention. The more we have voices around the world who agree with us, the more support we’ll have for this idea.” (Ha’aretz, Sept. 23)

 “Words matter… When people say: 'Don't pay too much attention, they don't mean it'­it reminds me of my grandfather in Hamburg, who read Mein Kampf, and he took it for real, but many other people didn't. Because everyone takes for granted Ahmadinejad's statements on Israel, people take for granted that it's kind of unique danger for Israel, because of the specific threats to another country.”­ Former U.S. ambassador Richard Holbrooke, along with Ambassador Dore Gold and other scholars, lawmakers, and survivors of the Rwandan and Darfur genocides, supporting the initiative to bring the Iranian president before an international tribunal. The group, which met for a conference in Washington on Tuesday, said Ahmadinejad's pronouncements are alarmingly similar to the coded statements of incitement that preceded the Rwandan genocide of the Tutsis in 1994, which the international community failed to prevent. (Ha’aretz, Sept. 23)

 “Watching both the U.S. and Israeli elections simultaneously, I cannot help thinking that in order to resolve the Palestinian problem, Israel must first reform its crippling political system. Israel needs a prime minister who serves for a full four years without fear of weekly police probes, and who can choose cabinet members on the basis of their qualifications and not their political power. Israel needs a system much more similar to America's.”­ Historian Michael B. Oren, discussing the fractious nature of Israel’s proportional representation system, and the state of Israeli politics in general. (National Post, September 19)

SHORT TAKES

POLL: PALESTINIANS SUPPORT FATAH­ (Nablus) A poll by A-Najah University in Nablus has found that twenty-eight per cent of Palestinians ­eight-hundred sixty from the West Bank, five hundred from the Gaza Strip, and all eligible to vote­would support an initiative to create a joint Jordanian-Palestinian state. More than half of the respondents prefer the current Israeli negotiations with the PA, while support for Hamas declined dramatically since they were elected to govern Gaza in 2006. Thirty-six per cent favour Fatah, less than fifteen per cent favour Hamas, and two per cent back Islamic Jihad. (Ha’aretz, September 23)

FRANCE 2 AGREES TO AL-DURA INVESTIGATION­ (Paris) France 2, the state-owned television network that sued media-watchdog Phillipe Karsenty for libel when he accused France 2 of airing a staged and doctored report, has agreed under pressure from the Anti-Defamation League to open an independent, private investigation of the September, 2000 Muhammed al-Dura broadcast. The libel suit was appealed and finally overturned earlier this year, since the authenticity of the video, reportedly showing IDF soldiers killing an innocent Palestinian boy, proved inconclusive. Now the station has agreed to allow a panel of experts headed by EU parliamentarian and International League Against Racism and Anti-Semitism chair Patrick Gaubert to examine the video and report. (Jer. Post, September 19)
 
TERRORISM IN JERUSALEM ­(Jerusalem) Jerusalem was struck again, this week, by vehicular terrorism when Qassem Mughrabi rammed his car into a group of soldiers in central Jerusalem. The nineteen-year-old was member of Hamas and lived in East Jerusalem’s Jebl Mukaber village, also home to the terrorist who killed eight students in March. Mughrabi’s rampage injured fifteen people before an off-duty IDF officer shot him dead. (Jerusalem Post, Sept. 22; Ha’aretz, Sept. 23)

MOTHER CONVICTED OF HELPING TERRORIST­ (Montreal) A judge has ruled that the mother of the boy convicted of firebombing the United Talmud Torahs School in St. Laurent, Québec in 2004 is guilty of being an accessory after a crime. The judge ruled that Rouba Elmerhebi Fahd knew that Sleiman Elmerhebi, currently serving forty months after having confessed to the crime, had set the fire and that minutes after the police visited Sleiman, she contacted a travel agent to procure a flight to Brazil for him. (Gazette (Montreal), September 19)

ANTISEMITISM ON THE RISE (Chicago) A report by the Pew Research Center on global attitudes released last week reveals that anti-Jewish and anti-Muslim sentiment is rising in Europe. Only Britain did not show a substantial increase in antisemitic attitudes: nine per cent in Britain, seven in the U.S. and eleven in Australia thought poorly of Jews, compared with twenty in France, twenty-five per cent in Germany, thirty-four in Russia, thirty-six in Poland, and forty-six in Spain. (Reuters, September 18)

 

 

Yale Initiative for the Interdisciplinary Study of Antisemitism | ISPS | yiisa.program@yale.edu