Yale Law School Home Page
Advanced Legal Research Robert Harrison, Blair Kauffman, Lisa Spar
Spring 1999

LEGAL RESEARCH: METHODS AND SOURCES
Spring 1999
Outline and Readings

Week of:1/27, 2/3, 2/10, 2/17, 2/24, 3/3, 3/10, 3/17, 3/24, 3/31, 4/7, 4/14, 4/21, 4/28, 5/5
Jan. 27





Introduction; Overview of the course; Introduction to law reports; Introduction to computer based research

Legal Research in a Nutshell ("Nutshell"): ch. 1 & 2
Discovering Westlaw, 8th ed. ("DW"): skim ch. 2; read ch. 4-6

Outline:
Course description and requirements.

Case reports; nature of the appellate decision in general and its components; development of law reporting and modern forms of publication. Types of reports: official and unofficial; state and federal reports; annotated and topical reporters.

The U.S. Supreme Court and its reports: the early nominative reporters; the quick text of decisions; slip decisions to advance sheet to bound volume; the official U.S. Reports, and the unofficial Supreme Court Reporter and Lawyers Edition. Lower federal court reports, including Federal Reporter, Federal Supplementand Federal Rules Decisions. State court reports: official and unofficial, including West regional reporters.

Introduction to LEXIS, WESTLAW, and the Internet.

Feb.3:




Case Finding (including Legal Encyclopedias, A.L.R. annotations, Digests, and Computer Services)

Nutshell: ch. 3 & 4
DW: ch. 7

Outline:
How to formulate research strategies for using legal encyclopedias, including Am. Jur. 2d, Corpus Juris Secundum, and state encyclopedias; indexing systems, organization, special features, and updating of encyclopedias; interrelations between Am. Jur. 2d and A.L.R., and between C.J.S. and the West Digests.

Annotated reporters: American Law Reports ("A.L.R."), including access to the A.L.R. system by case, index, digests, and statutory tables; analysis of typical annotation; research value of the annotation.

The National Reporter System: its rationale and components; headnotes and key-number indexing and digesting.

Case digests: The West digest system, from the advance sheet key number digest to the general digest to the decennials, etc.; federal, regional, and state digests; access to digests via table of cases, defendant-plaintiff table, title index, and descriptive word index; locating parallel citations; words and phrases; coordinating use of digests with other search tools.

Computerized search services for case law: LEXIS, WESTLAW, CD-ROM, and Internet

Feb. 10



Case-Finding (concluded) & Shepardizing Cases

Nutshell: review ch. 3; read ch. 5
DW: ch. 3, 8









Outline:
Case digests (concluded)

Shepard's Citations: The importance of Shepardizing; how to do a complete Shepard's search; using Shepard's to determine parallel citations, and the history and treatment of the cited case; symbols illustrating history and treatment; use of reporter headnotes to facilitate Shepardizing; dual purpose of citators to verify status and authority of case and to develop further research leads; difference in coverage between Shepard's for official reports and unofficial reports.

Feb. 17





Statutes (Federal and State) & Shepardizing Statutes

Nutshell: ch. 6
DW: ch. 9
Article: Desert, "Westlaw's Natural v. Boolean Searching: A Performance Study," 85 Law Library Journal 713 (on Web page)

Outline:
Types of legislation: constitutions; public and private acts; resolutions.

Forms of federal legislation: Slip laws; Statutes at Large; U.S.C.C.A.N; Revised Statutes; U.S. Code; the elements, uses, features, and advantages of annotated codes (U.S.C.A. and U.S.C.S.); the authoritative text of federal statutes.

Working with statutes: statutory indexes and tables; access to statutory material though descriptive word and title indexes, and popular names tables.

Shepardizing statutory material: history of legislation and judicial treatment; symbols indicating history and treatment; secondary research leads from statutory citators.













Feb. 24



Federal Legislative History

Nutshell: ch. 7

Outline:
Legislative history: ambiguity and problems of statutory interpretation; determination of legislative intent; steps in the legislative process and main documentary sources: bills, databases, committee reports, hearings, Presidential messages; use of status tables for determining current status and for tracing history retrospectively; compiled legislative histories; micro facsimile series; federal sources: the Congressional Record; Daily Digest; Calendars; Digests of Public Bills; U.S.C.C.A.N.; Congressional Quarterly; CCH Congressional Index; Congressional Index Service; the Serial Set and the C.I.S. indexes.

Researching constitutional and legislative history by using computerized sources, general databases, and searching in topical databases on LEXIS and WESTLAW.

Mar. 3









Updating Research

Nutshell: review ch. 3, § 3; ch. 6, § 5
DW: ch. 8
Articles: Dabney, "The Curse of Thamus: An Analysis of Full Text Legal Document Retrieval," 78 Law Library Journal 5

Dabney, "A Reply to West Publishing Company and Mead Data Central on The Curse of Thamus 78 Law Library Journal 349

The development, current, and future use of citators for finding and updating the law.

Outline:
Shepard's and Auto-Cite on LEXIS and KeyCite on WESTLAW.

Mar. 10



Federal Administrative Law

Nutshell: ch. 8

Outline:
The growth of administrative agencies and the development of the administrative process; adjudication, rule-making, and enforcement functions; the literature of administrative law: decisional and legislative.

Forms of publication: official and unofficial administrative reports; slip decisions and preliminary forms; the Code of Federal Regulations ("C.F.R.") and the Federal Register; official and unofficial indexes to C.F.R.

Updating administrative regulation using the monthly List of C.F.R. Sections Affected and its counterparts in the Federal Register; Shepard's citators for administrative law.

Using computer services to research Administrative Law: Federal Register, C.F.R., and topical databases on LEXIS and WESTLAW.

Mar. 17

Spring Recess

Mar. 24



Secondary Materials: Legal and Non-Legal; Looseleafs

Nutshell: ch. 9 & 11; ch. 10, §§ 1-3
DW: ch. 11

Outline:
The nature of authority in secondary materials; evaluation of secondary sources; judicial treatment.

Treatises: scholarly treatises, hornbooks, monographs, dissertations, casebooks, and practitioners' guides; finding tools for monographic sources; Restatements of the Law; computer access to secondary materials.

Legal periodicals: Indexes to periodical literature; legal newspapers and newsletters; computer access to periodicals.

Use of looseleaf services as a coordinated source of administrative, legislative, and judicial materials; forms of organization and methods of approach; variety of indexes; topical reporters as spinoffs.














March 31



Federal and State Court Rules & Litigation Materials: Records and Briefs, Jury Verdicts and Settlements, Public Records and Filings.

Nutshell: ch. 10, §§ 4-5

Outline:
Literature of procedural law; types of sources (rules of practice, practice acts, interpretive decisions); practice books.

Federal court rules: texts of rules; judicial interpretations; Shepardizing; secondary sources; state court rules.

Forms and formbooks: generalized and specialized sources; annotated forms; computer-assisted drafting.

April 7



International Law (including Treaties)

Nutshell: ch. 12 & 13

Outline:
International law sources; the traditional law of nations; treaty collections; the literature ofinternational organizations and tribunals; the League of Nations, the U.N., and their affiliated organizations; the P.C.I.J and I.C.J. regional organizations; secondary literature, including commentaries, treatises, periodicals, and digests; bibliographic guides to international law and foreign relations; research procedures and strategy.

U.S. treaties and U.S. practice in international law.

April 14



Constitutional Law & Local Law

Nutshell: review ch. 6, §§ 3, 7-8
DW: ch. 12

Outline
Historical background and sources of the U.S. Constitution; federal constitutional research; Shepardizing constitutional provisions; secondary sources; legislative history of constitutional provisions; constitutional research using computers.

State constitutions: texts, judicial interpretation; Shepardizing; secondary sources; legislative history; historical research.

Local law and government; city charters and codes of ordinances; N.I.M.L.O and Municipal Yearbook; finding ordinances; Shepardizing ordinances; secondary materials.

April 21



Legal Research Fun and Games

No Reading

Outline:
Teams compete for fun and prizes--mostly fun; game-show format with questions on all aspects of legal research.

April 28




Individual Options (Bioethical and Medical-Legal Research; or English and Canadian Legal Research; or Federal Taxation Research)

Nutshell: As appropriate

Outline:
Students may choose to attend any one of three sessions devoted to the topics listed above.

May 5



Coordinating Legal Research and Legal Writing in the Law Library and the Workplace

No Reading

Outline:
Taking notes in the law library: The "Two-Pad" Method; when to stop researching; how to move easily from finishing research to finishing the written product.

Things to do before you get to your job; survival tips for new lawyers.


Page URL(http://www.yale.edu/lawweb/lawcrs/lassyll.htm) [ Go to Top of Page ] [ Go back to Menu ] [ Yale Law School Home Page ]