| Author: | Edgar Günther Hertwich |
| Title: | Toxic Equivalency:
Addressing Human Health Effects in Life Cycle Impact Assessment |
| Institution: | Energy and Resources Group, UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY |
| Date: | 22 May 1999 |
| Advisor: | Catherine P. Koshland, William S. Pease |
| Key Words: | Life-Cycle Assessment, Impact Assessment, Human Health, Potential Dose, Fugacity |
| How to Obtain: | The dissertation can be obtained from UMI (http://www.umi.com/hp/Products/Dissertations.html) or from the author, Edgar Hertwich, LCA Laboratory, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Kolbjørn Hejesvei 2b, 7034 Trondheim, Norway, Tel. +47-73-59 8280, Fax +47-73-59 0110, hertwich@design.ntnu.no. |
| Abstract: | Comparative evaluation rests on science to describe actions of environmental
stressors and on values to judge the detriment of the consequences.
A step-wise comparison, starting with similar stressors, simplifies the
analysis. To clarify the interaction between science and values,
I suggest to distinguish among factual, normative, and relational truth
claims. Relational claims address the relation of factual knowledge
and values and should follow the rules of logic. Arguments about
impact assessment method development are relational and need to refer to
normative judgments as well as scientific knowledge to be rational.
A decision-analytic framework provides a consistent, systematic structure
for impact assessment. Similar stressors, such as toxic chemicals,
are evaluated by constructed attributes, such as HTP. These attributes
relate to our fundamental objectives through causal relationships. Decision
analysis provides criteria for method development.
The Human Toxicity Potential (HTP) is a weighting factor that expresses
the release of a toxic chemical in terms of an equivalent release of a
reference chemical. It is based on the toxicity of a chemical as
well as its potential dose. Applicable measures of toxicity are U.S.
EPA’s cancer potency and reference dose. The potential dose is evaluated
by a multimedia, multiple pathway fate and exposure model, CalTOX.
CalTOX determines pollutant concentrations in uniformly mixed environmental
compartments from intercompartmental mass transfer equations. It models
exposure pathways using partitioning and biotransfer relationships.
The potential dose is based on exposure media concentrations, diet, and
activity pattern.
|