Senior Essays 2001 (Abstracts)

The Environmental Studies Program Office has the full manuscripts.

Viviann Chui, Political Science and STEV
The Mis(communication) of Climate Change: Media Coverage of Scientific Uncertainty

Dylan Fuge, G&G and STEV
The Clarks Forks River System, Butte, Montana - An Examination of Contamination Caused by Copper Mining and the Potential for the Regions Rehabilitation: A Scientific and Policy Perspective

Megan MacLeod, MCDB and STEV
Heat Shock Proteins: Cellular Superheroes in the Face of Environmental Pollution

Josh Mukhopadhyay, Biology and STEV
Monodominant Ecosystems and Their Impact on Forest Management: The Case of Guadua weberbaueri in Southeastern Peru

Eric Shelov, G&G and STEV
The Potential for Metal Recovery in the Palmerton Zinc Pile

Nicholas Stucky, Biomedical Engineering and STEV
Assessing Carbon Sequestration in Agro-forests with Satellite Remote Sensing

Previous Year


Reports

The Mis(communication) of Climate Change:
Media Coverage of Scientific Uncertainty

Viviann Chui

Majors: Political Science and STEV
Advisor: Sylvia Tesh, Political Science, F&ES

For the past twenty years, climate change science has been plagued by terms such as "uncertainty," "debate," and "controversy." Skeptics, who have been the subjects of nearly half of the media coverage on climate change, have capitalized on this uncertainty for the greater part of the issue`s life-span. President Bush and those in his Administration continue to invoke scientific uncertainty as a rationale to postpone action on climate change in favor of further research. This stalling exists despite the publication of three assessment reports by the International Panel on Climate Change, the third of which provides a compelling explanation of humankind¹s discernible fingerprint on global climate. Oft-mentioned uncertainty has undermined efforts to properly pursue a discourse on global warming. Instead, what has occurred has been a miscommunication between both scientists and the media, and between the media and the public. Pushed by the journalistic credo of presenting both sides of a story, the media has portrayed climate change as a persisting duel among scientists. This paper employs a qualitative analysis of The New York Times from the past ten years to determine if the media is still presenting climate change as a science of uncertainty. Meanwhile, scientists true to the Scientific Method have been reluctant to publicly assert the seriousness of this issue for fear of compromising scientific objectivity. This paper will look at some the reasons for this and attempt to understand the cultures of science and the media to determine why the two behave the way they do. This paper makes the claim that human-induced climate change is a real phenomenon, and that the majority of climate scientists are in agreement with this conclusion. Thus, rather than disputing the scientific claims of global warming science, we look to the communicators of this science to determine where the gaps in knowledge have occurred. Hopefully, doing so will enable us to pinpoint the sources of (mis)information so that we can better improve the public`s understanding of global warming and mobilize them to make decisions consistent with future predicted impacts.

Top


The Clark Fork River System, Butte, Montana - An Examination of Contamination Caused by Copper Mining and The Potential for the Region`s Rehabilitation: A Scientific and Policy Perspective

Dylan Fuge

Majors: G&G and STEV
Advisor: Robert Gordon, G&G

At the turn of the century Butte, Montana was known as the `richest hill` on earth due to the rich copper deposits it contained.  From 1864 until the operations of the Anaconda Mining Company ceased in 1983, Butte dominated global copper production.  Unfortunately, extensive contamination often accompanies large-scale mineral production.  Butte, located at the headwaters of the Clark Fork River, is home to the largest Superfund site in the United States.  Over 350 million tons of contaminated sediments and mine wastes are found in the river`s floodplain.  The elevated levels of these metals, specifically copper and arsenic, are harmful to both the riparian and terrestrial ecosystems.  The extensive nature of the contamination is due to careless disposal in and along the Clark Fork`s tributaries, because waterborne sediment is an effective vector for these pollutants.

Butte`s legacy is tragic; 120 years of mining scarred the landscape and turned deserted areas into boomtowns that collapsed as soon as mining stopped.  Today, Butte is an abandoned industrial town in southwestern Montana.  Piles of mine wastes and remnants of old mine shafts litter the area.  The best example of this phenomenon is the Berkeley Pit, a former strip mine that is 1.5 miles across and over 1900 feet deep that dominates the center of town.  The pit is partially filled with water so toxic that when a flock of migrating geese landed on it they were killed instantly.  Since the 1960`s Butte had been faced with a shrinking population and mounting cleanup costs.

However, Butte does provide some hope.  A recent court decision, though questionable in its assignment of responsibility, has made 260 million dollars available for the cleanup effort.  Grass root efforts have seized and opportunity to turn Butte`s polluted past into the cities economic salvation.  The city of Butte and its residents have taken the initial steps on plan that will allow it to cleanup its toxic past, and celebrate its legacy as one of history`s most significant mineral lodes.

As the world`s population continues to grow Butte`s example will become important.  When the last pristine places are gone society will have to be able to inhabit and reuse formerly contaminated places.  Butte exemplifies this process because its residents are struggling to make a home in this contaminated city.  At the same time as Butte highlights the inadequacies of current environmental regulations it also demonstrates that environmental remediation that respects economics and ecosystem health is possible.

Top


Heat Shock Proteins:
Cellular Superheroes in the Face of Environmental Pollution

Megan MacLeod

Majors: MCDB and STEV
Advisors: Michael Kashgarian, MCDB and Pathology
Brian Leaderer, Epidemiology and Public Health

Heat shock proteins are a homologous class of proteins discovered in the 1970`s.  Researchers at the time determined the lethal high temperature for Drosophila flies in the laboratory.  But subsequent studies showed that fly populations pretreated with sublethal levels of heat could survive at fatal temperatures.  This phenomenon, where an organism`s critical temperature threshold is raised from earlier heat shocks, was termed `induced stress tolerance`.  When a class of proteins were found to be upregulated in the flies` cells due to this process, they were named `heat shock proteins` (HSPs) after these breakthrough experiments and they became the suspected cause of the flies` newfound heat tolerance. A number of studies since HSPs` original discovery shows that they are ubiquitously upregulated after a variety of injuries, not just heat shock, in order to protect the cell.  Furthermore, they protect the cells of almost all organisms and their sequence across species is highly conserved.  This sequence conservation, despite evolutionary influences, signals its inherent importance in living organisms across time.  HSPs confer protection by refolding damaged proteins, by stabilizing the cytoskeleton, by "chaperoning" lost proteins back to their location, and by blocking programmed cell death (apoptosis) after injury.  Medical researchers hope that HSPs have future clinical and therapeutic applications while environmental epidemiologists anticipate their use as biomarkers of exposure.  Most recently, environmentalists have tried to link heat shock protein levels in aquatic animals with the amount of contamination in natural habitats.  These studies have met with little success.  But HSPs continue to be used in laboratory research to indicate relative magnitudes of injury at the cellular level.  This study 1) examines the degree of apoptotic, necrotic, and overall injury protection afforded by HSP 27 in cell culture systems of pig kidney through apoptosis assays, necrosis assays, and Na/K ATPase localization studies 2) attempts to determine the site of HSP 27 interaction in the apoptotic pathway through Western blots of pathway proteins in pig kidney and3) observes the change in the heat shock 72 response after injury in conjunction with the environmental toxin nitric oxide (NO) in pig kidney and rat lung epithelia.  We conclude 1) that HSP 27 protects LLCPK1 pig kidney cells from cell death and overall injury after short exposures and 2) that NO depresses the HSP 72 injury response after short exposures in both pig kidney and L2 rat lung epithelia cells, thereby increasing susceptibility to cell injury.

Top


Monodominant Ecosystems and Their Impacts on Forest Management:
The Case of Guadua weberbaueri in Southeastern Peru

Josh Mukhopadhyay

Majors: Biology and STEV
Advisors: Mark Ashton, F&ES
Mary Helen Goldsmith, MCDB

Biodiversity is a term that has lately transcended discussion in purely scientific circles to become a household word, and moreover one that is invariably linked with public concern over the well being of the earth`s vital storehouse of genetic information.  Numerous efforts are underway by academics, federal agencies, and non-governmental organizations everywhere to quickly document the world`s so-called biodiversity `hotspots,` areas of inordinately high species richness, so that the requisite knowledge for planning conservation efforts is at least available.  Influential groups ranging from Conservation International to UNESCO have unanimously designated the forested areas flanking the Tropical Andes as just such a hotspot.  Though available data is still sparse, areas within this zone, such as Peru`s Tambopata-Candamo Reserved Zone (TCRZ), hold world records for both floral and faunal diversity per unit area ` a single hectare plot chosen at random may easily have more than 300 species of trees.  Contrast that with a similar slice of New England, where one is lucky to find more than a dozen such species.  However, within this treasure chest of species, there are areas that severely buck the trend, and studying the underlying ecology can reveal much about the dynamics of these important, yet little-known areas.

Huge swaths of rainforest all over this area, but especially in my study area, the aforementioned TCRZ, are covered by bamboo-dominated forest.  In areas such as this, the canopy is comprised solely of a single bamboo species, with a thick tangle of only a few understory species below.  Contrast this with adjacent plots that may be dominated by more familiar tropical hardwoods, and the differences are stark.  In a few steps` walk one can go from areas containing hundreds of plant species per hectare to areas containing less than ten.  Species such as bamboo are grouped in the early-successional category; plants that are quick to invade disturbed areas, but which also cannot compete with more robust and long-lived species such as hardwoods, which inevitably replace them.  It seems that the bamboo-rich zones, almost exclusively comprised of the species Guadua weberbaueri, somehow manage to stall succession and even expand into neighboring zones.  My project examined the physiological and site-related factors that may be able to explain this trend, concentrating on the differing light environments below bamboo and non-bamboo canopies.  The effect of canopy type on the makeup of the understory communities was also examined.  Several economically valuable understory palm species, including Geonoma deversa, which are used to thatch roofs were closely examined in this regard, and a sustainable harvest management regime for such non-timber forest products was formulated.  Analysis of remote sensing data was used to attempt an estimation of the ebb and flow of these varied plant communities over time, as using satellite-derived data is the only choice in regions where human history is short-lived.  If areas like the TCRZ are to be successfully managed for the benefit of future generations worldwide, while preserving access and economic benefits for local peoples, studies of this type provide valuable information.

Top


The Potential for Metal Recovery in the Palmerton Zinc Pile

Eric Shelov

Majors: G&G and STEV  
Advisor: Robert Gordon, G&G

This paper is an examination of the Palmerton Zinc Pile in Palmerton, Pennsylvania. From 1898 to 1985, the New Jersey Zinc Company operated two smelters that processed concentrated Lead and Zinc ores from many domestic mining regions. The smelter is located at the northern base of Blue Mountain and runs along the Aquashicola Creek, close to where it merges with the Lehigh River. During its century of operation, the New Jersey Zinc smelter deposited its residues in a cinder bank. The bank sits between the plant and the mountain, and it currently stands 2.3 miles long, covering 200 acres and averaging 100 feet in depth. The bank contains an estimated 30 million tons of materials, most of which are residues from pyrometallurgical processes. While depositing the residues in the bank, the company continually had future utilization in mind, and segregated the waste according to type and chemical composition, with the goal that some areas could eventually be reclaimed for their metal values. The cinder bank is divided into eight zones based on the process that produced the enclosed residues. The concentrations of materials vary greatly by zone, with zinc concentrations ranging from 2-10%. The first part of this paper is a historical investigation of the residues in each zone, the ores that were processed to make them, and how and where those ore bodies were formed. In addition, several of the zones with higher zinc concentrations will be presented, and a brief outline of their recovery past and potential future. There are currently no recovery methods that have proven economically feasible at this point, and while some newer technologies will be presented, a full feasibility study is well beyond the scope of this paper.

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency began seriously investigating the plant in 1980, and eventually forced it to shut down in 1985. In addition to the cinder bank, the EPA also has operable units addressing deforestation of the northern slope of Blue Mountain, the local community soils, and groundwater contamination. The second part of this paper is a brief examination of the EPA`s involvement in the site. Although the EPA has discovered many potential threats to human health in the area, including water and soil contamination, a large portion of the community opposes its actions, deeming them pointless and a waste of valuable resources.

Top


Assessing Carbon Sequestration in Agro-forests with Satellite Remote Sensing

Nicholas Stucky

Majors: Biomedical Engineering and STEV
Advisors: Mark Ashton, F&ES
Prasad Thenkabail, G&G

Most of the land in Western Africa has been developed for agricultural purposes to meet the growing nutritional and energy needs of the ballooning population. Now world environmental organizations have targeted these tropical forest and savannah climates as primary locations for carbon sequestration in accordance with the carbon budget plan put forth at the Kyoto Conference. The most viable plans for carbon sequestration involve the use of agro-forests because these areas can be managed to balance economically necessary short-term production with long-term carbon sequestration. This study identifies specific oil palm agro-forest regions in the Zouzouvou area in the Republic of Benin and calculates a normalized differential vegetation index (NDVI). The NDVI is then correlated with the ground truth data collected in West Africa in October of 2000. Using existing literature and models for calculating carbon sequestration and biomass from ground truth data the process image is used to assess the current baseline carbon sequestration of oil palm agro-forest in the region and demonstrate the ability to estimate carbon sequestration values accurately and efficiently with remote sensing techniques.

Top   |   Student Work   |   Previous Year